Welcome to Train Your Dog Month, where our focus is on fostering positive relationships between you and your furry friend! In this special edition, we address a sensitive topic — aversive dog training tools. While we do not endorse their use, it’s crucial to understand what these tools are and the reasons to avoid them. Join us as we delve into the world of aversive tools, shedding light on their impact and providing alternative, positive training methods for a healthier, happier bond with your canine companion.
What are Aversive Dog Training Tools?
Aversive dog training tools encompass a range of devices and techniques designed to discourage unwanted behaviour through the application of discomfort or fear. Common examples include prong collars, shock collars, and choke chains. These tools are often used as a form of punishment to deter dogs from specific actions. Unfortunately, relying on aversives can lead to unintended consequences, including increased anxiety, fear, and a breakdown in the human-animal bond. Such methods may suppress behaviour temporarily, but they fail to address the underlying causes and can result in heightened stress levels and potential long-term behavioural issues. It’s essential to approach dog training with empathy and positive reinforcement to build trust and create a harmonious relationship based on mutual understanding. For more: Do No Harm Dog Training® by Linda Michaels: A Compassionate Approach to Training Your Dog
Definitions of commonly used Aversive Dog Training Tools
Aversive Dog Training Tool: Prong Collar
A prong collar, also known as a pinch collar, is a dog training collar designed with a series of metal links equipped with inward-facing prongs. When tension is applied, these prongs can create discomfort or pinching sensations on a dog’s neck, serving as a correction tool during training. While some trainers argue that prong collars can be effective for controlling strong or reactive dogs, they are considered aversive and controversial. Critics emphasise the potential for causing physical harm, fear, and anxiety in dogs. Positive reinforcement methods are generally recommended as alternatives for promoting a more humane and effective approach to training.
Aversive Tool: Shock Collar or E-Collars
A shock collar, also known as an electronic or e-collar, is a training device that delivers an electric stimulus, typically through metal prongs, to a dog’s neck in response to a remote-controlled signal. Used for behaviour correction, these collars are designed to create discomfort or a mild electric shock. While proponents argue for their effectiveness, shock collars are widely criticised due to the potential for inducing fear, anxiety, and physical harm in dogs. Positive reinforcement methods are generally recommended as humane alternatives for training.
It’s important to note that electronic collars, commonly known as e-collars or shock collars, have faced scrutiny and are banned or restricted in several countries due to ethical and welfare concerns. These bans reflect a growing awareness of the potential adverse effects of using electric stimuli for training, such as inducing fear, anxiety, and physical harm in dogs. As responsible dog owners, it’s crucial to stay informed about the regulations in your region and prioritize humane training methods that focus on positive reinforcement. Choosing alternatives that foster a trusting and respectful relationship between you and your canine companion is key to promoting their well-being and long-term behavioral success.
Choke Chains
A choke chain is a metal chain looped through itself, creating a collar that tightens around a dog’s neck when tension is applied. Used for correction during training, a choke chain is designed to tighten momentarily to discourage unwanted behaviour. However, it poses risks, as improper use can lead to injury, tracheal damage, or behavioural issues. Due to the potential for harm and the availability of more humane training alternatives, choke chains are generally discouraged in favour of positive reinforcement methods that strengthen the bond between dogs and their owners.
Let’s talk Choke Chains, Slip Leads and Martingale Collars
Let’s start with slip leads. You’ve probably seen them before – they’re those simple collar and leash combinations that tighten when tension is applied. While slip leads can be great for quick walks and training sessions, they sometimes get a bad rap because they look similar to choke chains.
Unlike choke chains, which constrict around a dog’s neck with pressure, potentially causing discomfort or even pain, slip leads typically function more like regular collars that tighten slightly when tension is applied but should not choke the dog. I say should , some slip leads are designed to function similarly to choke chains though! Tightening around the dog’s neck when tension is applied. This design can potentially lead to discomfort or even injury, especially if used improperly or with excessive force.
Let’s quickly talk about martingale collars. These collars are designed with an extra loop that tightens gently when your dog pulls on the leash, preventing them from slipping out of the collar. Martingale collars are often recommended for dogs who tend to back out of their collars or for breeds with narrower heads.
To sum this up:
If you use any tool with the intention or purpose of enforcing a behaviour and compliance because the alternative is pain or discomfort, then imho you can consider this aversive!
When selecting a slip lead or any training equipment for your dog, it’s essential to prioritise their comfort, safety, and well-being. Look for slip leads that are specifically designed with features to prevent choking, such as wider or padded sections around the neck, or ones made from softer materials that distribute pressure more evenly.
Additionally, always use training equipment responsibly and with care. Avoid yanking or jerking on the leash, as this can cause unnecessary stress and discomfort for your dog. Instead, focus on gentle, positive reinforcement techniques to encourage desired behaviours and build a strong bond with your furry friend. More on this below!
If you’re unsure about which type of training equipment is best for your dog (harness and|or collar, training leashes etc.) or how to use it properly, don’t hesitate to seek guidance from a professional dog trainer or behaviourist (check for their credentials and ‘training style’). They can provide personalised advice and support to help you and your dog succeed in training while ensuring their safety and well-being.
Ultimately, whether you choose to use a slip lead, martingale collar, or any other training tool, always prioritise positive reinforcement, patience, and respect for your dog’s individual needs and preferences. Together, you can build a trusting and loving relationship based on mutual understanding and communication.
Reasons NOT to use Aversives and What to Do Instead!
There are several reasons why aversive training tools should be avoided when training dogs, and alternative positive reinforcement-based methods should be used instead. Here are some reasons:
- Potential physical and psychological harm: Aversive training tools, such as shock collars, prong collars, and choke collars, can cause physical pain, fear, anxiety, and stress in dogs. These tools rely on punishment to deter unwanted behaviours, and can result in adverse effects on a dog’s well-being, including physical injuries, psychological trauma, and decreased trust in their owner or handler.
- Risk of unintended consequences: Aversive training tools may suppress behaviours in the short term, but they may not address the underlying causes of the behaviour and can result in unintended consequences. For example, a dog may become fearful, anxious, or aggressive due to the use of aversive tools, which can exacerbate behavior problems or create new ones.
- Potential damage to the human-animal bond: The use of aversive training tools can strain the relationship between a dog and their owner or handler, as it relies on fear, intimidation, and punishment. This can damage the trust and bond between the two, leading to a breakdown in communication and cooperation.
- Lack of scientific support: The use of aversive training tools is not supported by the scientific community as a humane, effective, or necessary approach to dog training. Positive reinforcement-based methods, on the other hand, have been scientifically proven to be effective in modifying behaviour, building trust, and improving the overall well-being of dogs.
Alternatives to Aversive Dog Training Tools
Instead of using aversive training tools, positive reinforcement-based methods can be employed, which focus on rewarding desired behaviours rather than punishing unwanted behaviours.
Here are some alternatives:
- Reward-based training: This method involves using rewards, such as treats, praise, toys, or play, to reinforce desired behaviours. Dogs learn to repeat behaviours that result in positive outcomes, and unwanted behaviours are ignored or redirected to more appropriate behaviours.
- Clicker training: This form of positive reinforcement training uses a clicker, a small handheld device that makes a distinct clicking sound, to mark desired behaviours. The click is followed by a reward, creating a clear communication tool between the dog and the trainer.
- Relationship-building and bonding: Building a strong bond based on trust and mutual respect with the dog through positive interactions, training, and socialisation can lead to cooperative and willing behaviour.
- Management and prevention: Managing the dog’s environment to prevent opportunities for unwanted behaviours, such as using baby gates, leashes, or crates, can be effective in preventing the need for punishment-based training.
- Seeking professional help: Consulting with a qualified, positive reinforcement-based dog trainer or behaviourist can provide guidance and expertise in using humane and effective training methods that are tailored to the individual dog’s needs.
Using positive reinforcement-based methods not only promotes a healthy and positive relationship between the dog and the owner or handler, but also helps in building trust, improving communication, and enhancing the overall well-being of the dog.
German 
English